#24 Native American/Columbus Day

Happy Native American/Columbus Day! Celebrate OUR history that shaped where we are.

Steve Steele

10/12/20267 min read

a statue of a woman riding a white horse
a statue of a woman riding a white horse

The People Who Were Already Here

Today is one of those days on the calendar that means different things depending on where you're standing.

South Dakota officially celebrates Native American Day on the second Monday of October (and has since 1990) while roughly half of the country still calls it Columbus Day. Depending on your background, your community, and what you were taught in school, this Monday might feel like a celebration of exploration and Italian-American heritage, a recognition of Indigenous peoples and their contributions, a political argument you'd rather not have, or just a day off that you didn't think too deeply about.

I want to think deeply about it. Not to wade into the political version of the debate, but because I think a day that asks us to hold two complicated truths at once has something real to teach us about leadership, about community, and about the kind of people we are called to be in a world that doesn't always offer clean, simple answers.

Bear with me.

Two Things Can Be True

Here is the honest starting point: history is almost never a simple story with a clean hero and a clean villain. The leaders, the decisions, and the legacies that shaped the world we live in are almost always tangled full of courage and cruelty, vision and blindness, genuine achievement alongside genuine harm.

Columbus's voyages across the Atlantic in 1492 required extraordinary courage, remarkable navigation, and an audacity that is genuinely difficult to comprehend from the comfort of the modern world. They also set in motion a chain of events that brought devastating consequences to millions of people who were already here, had been here for thousands of years, and who built rich, complex civilizations long before a European ship appeared on their horizon.

Both of those things are true. At the same time. About the same history.

I thought about this through the lens of leadership this weekend. Because one of the most uncomfortable truths about being in a position of authority (as a coach, as an executive, as a parent, as anyone who makes decisions that affect other people's lives) is that your intentions and your impact are not always the same thing. You can mean well and still cause harm. You can build something genuinely remarkable and still leave a trail of cost behind it that you weren't paying attention to.

Being a Momentous Leader means paying attention to both.

Sitting Bull and the Weight of Seeing Clearly

Sitting Bull was a courageous warrior, statesman, and dedicated leader. He was one of South Dakota's first ambassadors to the world, and a man who remains an essential figure in South Dakota and United States history. He united the Sioux Tribes in their struggle for survival on the North American Great Plains.

I think about Sitting Bull in the same way as many other respected leaders. Not because of what he did when his circumstances were easy, but because of what he did when the circumstances were at their hardest. He led people who were being systematically stripped of their land, their way of life, their identity and refused to let them forget who they were. He led not from a position of power over his people, but from a position of service to them. He was chosen by those who followed him because he was worth following.

Though their contributions have often been overlooked, Native Americans have long had a profound impact on both their communities and the United States as a whole. For centuries, leaders including Tecumseh, Sequoyah, and Nanye'hi have left a lasting mark with their leadership, bravery, and innovations.

And yet how much of that history did most of us learn in school? How many of those names were on our reading lists? How many of those stories were told with the same depth and care as the stories of the explorers and founding fathers who arrived later?

The people who don't get the chapter in the textbook are often the people who most need a moment created for them. That principle lives at the heart of everything this blog has tried to say. It doesn't stop applying when the conversation gets historically complicated.

What Courage Actually Looked Like

I want to say something about Columbus that I think gets lost in the debate.

The film Young Washington aims to spark a new generation of civic engagement, contribution, and resilience. I mentioned after seeing that film that the version of a leader we remember in history is almost never the version who existed before the defining moments. Washington was shaped by failure and accountability. Columbus, for all the complexity of his legacy, was shaped by a willingness to sail into the unknown when the entire known world said the idea was impossible.

That kind of courage is real and deserves to be named. The ability to move toward something nobody else believes, to act on a conviction when the evidence for it is thin and the risk is enormous. That is a form of leadership that I recognize. It is the same disposition that drives anyone who has ever built something from scratch, started something no one thought would work, or taken a job that everyone around them thought was wrong for them.

What it is not, and what the fuller telling of the story requires us to say clearly, is the whole story. Courage in service of a vision does not automatically sanctify the methods or the consequences. Washington learned that at Fort Necessity. Columbus (by the available historical record) never fully reckoned with it at all. Upon arriving in the Bahamas, the explorer and his men forced the native peoples they found there into slavery.

Momentous Leaders that this blog is about are people who bring both things together: the courage to pursue what they believe in, and the awareness to see clearly what their pursuit costs the people around them. Not one or the other. Both.

The Overlooked Room, on a Historical Scale

I've written in previous posts about looking for the people the room isn't looking for. The players nobody was tracking. The coaches nobody was watching. The workers who showed up every day and built something without anyone stopping to acknowledge it.

Native American Day, at its best, is a national version of that practice. It is a collective moment of paying attention to a contribution, a presence, and a history that has too often been treated as background context rather than the main story. Here in South Dakota, there is a rich culture and nine Native American tribes. Their languages, their traditions, their ways of understanding the land and community and leadership are not historical relics. They are living things, carried forward by communities who have survived enormous pressure to disappear and have refused to.

The Boys & Girls Club work I do every day puts me in close contact with kids and families from all kinds of backgrounds. Kids who are navigating a world that doesn't always see them clearly, that doesn't always create moments for them, that doesn't always stop to ask what they carry or where they come from. Some of those kids carry Indigenous heritage. All of our children deserve to see their story treated as worth knowing.

That starts with adults who are willing to pay attention. Not just to the history that's comfortable and clean, but to the full picture of the complex, difficult, and necessary.

What a Leader Does with Complicated History

Here's where I want to land this, because I don't think the point of this post is to resolve a centuries-old debate. I'm not a historian, and I'm not going to pretend this space is the right one for that conversation.

What I am is a leader who has spent years trying to pay attention to the people in the room, including the ones the room isn't paying attention to. And what I believe, as deeply as I believe anything about leadership, is that the practice of seeing people clearly doesn't get to stop when the people are far away in time or geography or cultural familiarity.

Momentous Leadership asks you to notice who isn't being noticed. To create moments for the people who don't expect them. To see what's already in the room before you assume nothing was there.

Today is a good day to practice that on a wider canvas. Not with guilt or a political agenda. Just with the genuine willingness to look at a fuller picture of the world you live in and to acknowledge the people who were here before you arrived, the contributions that shaped the ground you stand on, and the leaders who led their communities through hardship that most of us cannot fully imagine, and to say, as clearly and as specifically as you can:

I see you. Your story matters. Thank you for still being here.

That's a moment worth creating. Even if nobody told you it was your job to create it.

PARTING THOUGHTS

  • Think about the community you live and work in with its land, its history, and the people who were there before the version of it you know. How much of that history do you actually know? What would it look like to learn more, not out of obligation, but out of genuine curiosity about the full story of the place you call home?

  • The Indigenous concept of leadership described leadership as voluntary following, or people chose their leaders simply by choosing to follow them. How does that definition challenge or sharpen the way you think about your own leadership? Are the people behind you there by structure, or by genuine choice?

  • Columbus had the courage to sail into the unknown, but was blind to see what it cost the people he encountered. Think honestly about the last significant decision you made in your leadership. Where was your vision clear, and where might you have had a blind spot about what it cost the people around you?

  • Native American Day, at its best, is about creating a moment for people who have too often been overlooked in the telling of the larger story. Who in your own program, organization, or community is being overlooked in the telling of your story? What would it look like to change that this week?

CONNECT

Reach out for speaking inquiries, book signings, or podcast appearances.

Email

Call

steve@themomentousleader.com

info@themomentousleader.com

605-220-1283

© 2026. All rights reserved.

FOLLOW